Nast-Curley was the third all-time leading scorer with 1,824 points and was the second all-time rebounder with 793. She also ranked in the top five for career field goals, field goal percentage, free throws, free throw percentage, and rebounding average. Nast-Curley was a two-time All MAAC selection, and was named honorable mention Academic All-American. As a senior she was team captain, and won the Claire G. Hobbs award as the Fordham Female Athlete of the Year.