A four year starter, Judge was named All-East at two different positions, and was co-captain of the 1979 team that was ranked eighth in the nation, while setting records as a swimmer. He later coached the squad, leading them to five MET titles and one Mid-Atlantic Championship.
 
After graduation, Judge continued playing water polo for the NYAC, where he earned All-America honors and was also a member of the U.S. National Water Polo team. In 1987, Chris's father, Francis X. Judge, was inducted into Fordham's Hall of Fame for water polo as well.