Chuck Felice was once Fordham's top man in the 200-meter freestyle with a time of 1:39.89. He is also a member of the record-setting quartet in the 800-meter freestyle relay along with fellow inductee Larry Cichanowicz. He formerly held the 200-meter butterfly record (time: 1:56.45) and the 400-meter medley relay (same race as Larry Cichanowicz; broken in 1987).